i cant comment on which is best as ive never competed (and never will) but do you think that the dirty bulk you did held you back? or do you think if you never did this dirty bulk and didnt get as big as you did you wouldnt have as much muscle mass as you do now?
One of those questions that could never be answered without a time machine lol.
I dont think about it too much to be honest, dwelling on what could have been etc
I still say i would of prefered to keep it leaner due to the issues i have no with still trying to shed the remaining stubborn fat



I've been trying to eat more in the hope that I can build muscle and the fact I do 6 sessions of cardio a week will continue to burn fat.